Edie and Viva

edie and viva

Edie Sedgwick and Viva on the set of Ciao! Manhattan (1972)

Edie and Viva

By Alexandra Auder

Looking back at John Palmer and David Weisman’s anomalous portrait of two Warhol superstars.

Ciao! Manhattan plays at Metrograph on Saturday, January 27, as part of The Whitney Review Salon.

I was hesitant to watch Ciao! Manhattan (1972) again. I hadn’t seen it for 30 years, and maybe I had never even finished watching it. In my head (and what’s in our heads turns out to be a central theme of Ciao!), I had written it off as silly. Not good. As the daughter of Viva and by extension a daughter of the Warhol scene, I’ve never been much seduced by… the Warhol scene. Though my mother loved Warhol in her own way, she also felt exploited by him, and was bitter about the fact that he never financially compensated her. I didn’t even bother to see the Whitney retrospective in 2018. That said, I did just publish a memoir about, well, among other things, growing up as a daughter of the counterculture, and in a funny way my book, Don’t Call Me Home, would be a great addendum to the film. 

Watching the film now, I got really into it. I was impressed, even creeped out by how prescient it was. Also, depressed by it. 

Ciao! was one of my mother’s first movies and Edie Sedgwick’s last. In the film, Edie’s alter ego is “Susan,” which happens to be my mother’s real name, before Warhol crowned her Viva Superstar. I was born in February of 1971, five years after my mother shot her scenes in Ciao!, but the famously ill-fated production was still going on. It was only a month before I was born that Edie finally finished shooting her last scenes and in November, nine months after I was born, she died of an overdose.

The story of how the Ciao! shoot was ill-fated and marred by money and drug problems is fairly well-documented, but the important thing to know is that Edie disappeared in the middle of the shoot, suffering from drug addiction and anorexia, ended up in a psych ward, and years later was busted out by one of the filmmakers, David Weisman, who convinced the doctors that he himself would watch over her. And by watch over he meant, literally: film her.  

When I finished watching Ciao! I was dying to ask my mother a thousand questions. Before the “plandemic” and my book, I could have called her and we would have laughed together and she would have told me stories about everyone in the film—her friends and enemies, most of them dead now. But I couldn’t call her. Not because Viva’s dead like Edie and Paul America—Edie’s boyfriend and co-star in Ciao! who disappeared along with her and ended up in jail, and Weisman convinced the prison warden to let him film Paul’s last scenes from his cell (oh, the ’60s)—no, my mother is alive and well, but she has mostly stopped talking to me.

ciao 2

Ciao! Manhattan (1972)

If I had been brave and texted her a few questions about the film, I’d likely get a text back about: the dangers of technology (a theme in Ciao!), or “the jab” (another theme, though in Ciao! it’s a speed-filled jab rather than a vaccine), or the nefarious qualities of men in power (yup, another theme in Ciao!), and/or a few sentences about how I’ve made up and/or imagined everything in my memoir (yet another Ciao! theme).

Viva is not in the movie much. Her scenes are all contained in the black-and-white flashbacks: Edie’s memories from the past, before she realized the Factory was “bullshit,” before she fell from grace. I watched my mother’s fleeting and floating scenes (she is beautifully naked in a pool for the majority of her screen time) with great awe, and also curiosity. Who is this woman? This woman, just before she became an Underground Superstar, just a few years before she became a mother—this slender, languid woman, so familiar and yet alien, naked with her pencil-thin arms around the anorexic shoulders of beautiful, doe-eyed Edie, the icon, with only a few more years to live, equally naked, equally languid, both of them smiling and laughing together. These two women—Edie and Viva—doing the opposite of what they were told to do by their rich, conservative parents, both fleeing childhood trauma inflicted by Silent Generation fathers, both refusing to fit in with prescribed societal behaviors, both taking a feminist stance and reveling in their (naked) freedom, and both suffering, on and off, from mental disorders (as a young woman Viva also spent time in a psych ward, however briefly).

In the present-day, California-set narrative of the film Viva and Edie have long parted ways, and also in reality their lives had taken very different turns. In real life, Viva had left the Warhol scene, published a critically acclaimed auto-fiction book about it, and was a new mother (to me). In the film, Edie is stumbling around in color, still topless but with fake breasts now, getting electroshock therapy (from doctor Roger Vadim), living in a tent-like construction at the bottom of an emptied-out pool ensconced in her film-mother’s Xanadu. Here, Edie tells the story of her past, a warning tinged with nostalgia, or her version of Slouching Towards Bethlehem. During a bucolic hippie scene featuring Allen Ginsburg in the film’s sub-narrative about a commune of “saucer People” living in a “villa for happy people,” we hear her voice-over: “That’s the revolution of the youth, sort of like a mockery, in a way, of reality. They think everything is smiles and sweetness and flowers when there is something bitter to taste, and to think there isn’t is foolish.”

Flash forward 50 years and many of Ciao!’s premonitions about capitalism, technology, and “the man” have been realized in America, and the residual anger from the collapse and death of the ’60s counterculture has turned a good amount of boomers into paranoid conspiracy theorists. (Bill Gates is the modern version of The Rich Man character, Mr. Verdecchio, who is secretly controlling everything in Ciao!) At the end of the film, Butch, the hapless hippie character who has failed at caretaking Edie, who has no idea what is real and what is not, who is trying to hitch a ride to Manhattan to get Mr. V to help him build his “saucer,” asks: “Who’s hustling who?”

Good question. I’d love to call my mother and laugh about it all, but I can’t. She’ll think I’m hustling her because I’m controlled by 5G.

Alexandra Auder is a writer and actor. She resides in Philadelphia with her husband and two children.

ciao 1

Ciao! Manhattan (1972)